News

Ranking Super Bowl Quarterback Matchups By Combined QBS

Posted on March 31, 2014 at 7:55 PM

Below is a list of post-merger Super Bowl quarterback matchups, ranked from highest to lowest by combined QBS.


  • XIX: Dan Marino (36.0) vs. Joe Montana (31.0) = 67.0
  • XLIV: Drew Brees (35.0) vs. Peyton Manning (31.0) = 66.0
  • XI: Ken Stabler (32.5) vs. Fran Tarkenton (30.0) = 62.5
  • XXVI: Jim Kelly (30.0) vs. Mark Rypien (26.0) = 56.0
  • XVI: Ken Anderson (33.0) vs. Joe Montana (18.0) = 51.0
  • XIII: Roger Staubach (28.0) vs. Terry Bradshaw (22.5) = 50.5
  • XXXI: Brett Favre (29.0) vs. Drew Bledsoe (20.0) = 49.0
  • XLVI: Tom Brady (32.0) vs. Eli Manning (16.0) = 48.0
  • XXXII: Brett Favre (29.0) vs. John Elway (18.0) = 47.0
  • XXXVII: Rich Gannon (32.0) vs. Brad Johnson (14.0) = 46.0
  • VI: Bob Griese (23.0) vs. Roger Staubach (21.0) = 44.0
  • XXVII: Troy Aikman (29.0) vs. Jim Kelly (15.0) = 44.0
  • XLVIII: Peyton Manning (37.0) vs. Russell Wilson (6.0) = 43.0
  • XXXVI: Kurt Warner (36.0) vs. Tom Brady (7.0) = 43.0
  • XXXIV: Kurt Warner (39.0) vs. Steve McNair (3.0) = 42.0
  • XII: Roger Staubach (34.0) vs. Craig Morton (7.0) = 41.0
  • XXIII: Boomer Esiason (25.5) vs. Joe Montana (15.0) = 40.5
  • XXIX: Steve Young (37.0) vs. Stan Humphries (2.0) = 39.0
  • VIII: Fran Tarkenton (27.0) vs. Bob Griese (11.0) = 38.0
  • XLI: Peyton Manning (37.0) vs. Rex Grossman (0.0) = 37.0
  • XLII: Tom Brady (40.0) vs. Eli Manning (-5.0) = 35.0
  • XL: Matt Hasselbeck (21.0) vs. Ben Roethlisberger (11.0) = 32.0
  • XXVIII: Troy Aikman (21.0) vs. Jim Kelly (10.5) = 31.5
  • X: Roger Staubach (17.0) vs. Terry Bradshaw (14.0) = 31.0
  • XVIII: Joe Theismann (26.0) vs. Jim Plunkett (4.5) = 30.5
  • XLV: Aaron Rodgers (23.0) vs. Ben Roethlisberger (7.0) = 30.0
  • XXXIX: Donovan McNabb (20.0) vs. Tom Brady (9.0) = 29.0
  • XXIV: Joe Montana (30.0) vs. John Elway (-2.5) = 27.5
  • XXV: Jim Kelly (26.0) vs. Jeff Hostetler (0.0) = 26.0
  • XLIII: Kurt Warner (29.5) vs. Ben Roethlisberger (-3.5) = 26.0
  • IX: Fran Tarkenton (23.0) vs. Terry Bradshaw (0.0) = 23.0
  • XXX: Troy Aikman (18.0) vs. Neil O'Donnell (5.0) = 23.0
  • XXXIII: Chris Chandler (13.0) vs. John Elway (8.0) = 21.0
  • VII: Billy Kilmer (21.0) vs. Bob Griese (0.0) = 21.0
  • XV: Ron Jaworski (20.0) vs. Jim Plunkett (0.0) = 20.0
  • XIV: Terry Bradshaw (19.5) vs. Vince Ferragamo (0.0) = 19.5
  • XVII: Joe Theismann (19.0) vs. David Woodley (0.0) = 19.0
  • XXII: John Elway (17.0) vs. Doug Williams (0.0) = 17.0
  • XXX: Troy Aikman (18.0) vs. Neil O'Donnell (5.0) = 13.0
  • XLVII: Colin Kaepernick (9.0) vs. Joe Flacco (0.0) = 9.0
  • XXI: John Elway (5.0) vs. Phil Simms (3.5) = 8.5
  • V: Craig Morton (10.0) vs. Johnny Unitas (-1.5) = 8.5
  • XX: Jim McMahon (7.0) vs. Tony Eason (1.0) = 8.0
  • XXXV: Kerry Collins (7.0) vs. Trent Dilfer (0.0) = 7.0
  • XXXVIII: Tom Brady (8.0) vs. Jake Delhomme (-2.0) = 6.0

Categories: None